Torture in interrogations essay

police interrogations Although the days where torture and third degree tactics in police interrogations were the norm are now gone, Didn't find an essay.

Cesare Beccaria: Of Crimes and Punishments

This Essay addresses the theoretical debate on torture in an empirical way. It urges that as part of our evaluation of the merits of torture, we take a shrewd look at the quality of information brutal interrogations produce. The Essay identifies widespread belief in what the author identifies as the "torture myth" the idea that torture is the most effective interrogation practice. In reality, in addition to its oft-acknowledged moral and legal problems, the use of torture carries with it a host of practical problems which seriously blunt its effectiveness. This Essay demonstrates that contrary to the myth, torture and the closely related practice, torture "lite" do not always produce the desired information and, in the cases in which it does, these practices may not produce it in a timely fashion. In the end, the Essay concludes, any marginal benefit the practice offers is low because traditional techniques of interrogation may be as good, and possibly even better at producing valuable intelligence.


How We Survived Two Years of Hell As Hostages in …

Answer to Evaluate Essay 16, "Torture: Time for Congress to End the Debate" and Essay 17, "Torture: Severe Interrogations Work" Which essay presents the

Enhanced Interrogation is Justified By: in part due to questions surrounding the morality and legality of torture as a Essay about Interrogations.


From mid—2003 to mid—2004, the manner in which the American Armed Forces handled detainees was called into question: the case of LTC West firing a pistol during the interrogation of a detainee in August 2003, photographs of nude men from the Abu Ghraib prison, and reports of Afghans/Iraqis dying while in U.S. custody. Overarching these events, there was an almost worldwide accusation that, 'Americans are torturing detainees!' In the arena of public opinion all these events were called 'torture' regardless of definition. Accordingly, this essay looks at these acts as torture through the prisms of some legal imperatives, the effectiveness of torture, why some resort to torture, trained interrogators, and a closing comment. It is not the purpose of this essay to demonstrate the U.S. Armed Forces' doctrinal techniques of interrogation that have been honed over the years and are known and used by both military and law enforcement agencies worldwide. But, I do feel obliged to shine a little light on some alternatives to torturing and/or abusing detainees. For the curious, I invite you to read the basic reference for trained U.S. military intelligence interrogators, FM 2—22.3 (FM 34—52) HUMAN INTELLIGENCE COLLECTOR OPERATIONS. You would also find illuminating the book: The Interrogator: The Story of Hanns Joachim Scharff Master Interrogator of the Luftwaffe. This German interrogator purportedly gleaned information from every one of the American and British fighter pilots he interrogated without ever resorting to violence. This is not surprising when you consider: FM 2—22.3 states that direct questioning 'works 90 to 95 percent of the time.' Even Gen Aussaresses admits in his book, 'most of the time I didn't need to resort to torture, but only talk to people.' Trained interrogators, of course, know this——the operant words here are, 'trained interrogators.' See theUN Declaration of Human Rights of 1948, or the UN Convention Against Torture of1984, both of which the has signed (for a much more thorough review of the relevant internationaltreaties and legal documents, see Kellberg (1998)).In this essay, I am concerned more so withthe morality of torture interrogation, less so with its legality.Confessions and interrogations. Published: 23rd March, 2015 Last Edited: 23rd March, 2015. This essay has been submitted by a student. This is not an example of the. See more info on this topic: A Proposal for Torture Interrogations and Confessions It is rather difficult to determine whether torture is ever acceptable. Name Professor Class 12 April 2012 Torture in Interrogation National security has always been a top priority for any country. With the recent developments in te. Win the war against al Qaeda and will continue to press detainees for leads. The controversial interrogation technique known as water boarding, in which a. Confessions and interrogations. Published: 23rd March, 2015 Last Edited: 23rd March, 2015. This essay has been submitted by a student. This is not an example of the.